Does Arizona Need "The Guardian" Blog?

You be the judge.

There are far too many families who are cast into the world of long term care without a lifeline or even a compass.

In my experience, there are no primers on what families can expect when a loved one is in long term care. Nor are there any guides to enable families to protect their loved ones from nursing home neglect or abuse.

This blog is for them.

There are also far too many nurses and nursing aides, working in long term care, who are victims of corporate financial decisions that make it impossible for them to provide quality care.

These health care professionals often have limited access to vital information thus preventing them from providing optimal patient care.  There are also few opportunities for these caregivers to engage in candid dialog with other professionals in a non-threatening environment.

This blog is for them.

Our Next Article.

Our next article will discuss the risks to patients in nursing homes and the principal causes of those risks.

The “Guardian Blog” will provide information to help both families and professionals assess and improve the quality of nursing home care in Arizona and the Guardian Blog will encourage dialog with and among its readers.
 

Nursing Homes Can Be Dangerous to your Health

Is it possible that a nursing home patient, in the United States, could starve to death while under the care of health professionals?

Well, to my dismay, I learned that the answer was yes. It is now over 12 years since two adult children came to my law firm and told me the story of their father. He was a stroke patient, in an Arizona nursing home, who died because he wasn’t given adequate assistance with eating.

So began my journey, representing families of injured and deceased nursing home patients who were neglected and abused.

No one chooses to live in a nursing home. It only becomes necessary when poor health or advanced age demands skilled nursing or rehabilitative care.

Quality Care.

“Quality Care” are words that have more than passing importance to families of nursing home patients. But what can families do to obtain that level of care for their loved ones?

Nursing homes, by federal mandate, are required to deliver quality care to every patient. That means every patient deserves attentive and professional nursing care as the primary purpose of a nursing home is to provide skilled nursing care.

As you will see, the greatest threat to quality care is inadequate nursing care.

Who is at Risk in a Nursing Home?

Although any patient in a nursing home can be at risk of not getting quality care, it is those patients who are non-ambulatory or who are unable to feed themselves that are at the greatest risk of being neglected and abused.

Frail patients, incapacitated patients or patients with dementia are also vulnerable to abuse and neglect because they lack the ability to protect themselves.

Appropriate Staffing is the Key of Good Care.

Nursing homes are dependent on nurses and nurses' aides to provide patient care. The appropriate number of nurses in a facility is dependent on the acuity and functional ability of the patients needing care. The greater the patient needs, the greater the number of nurses and nurses' aides required to care for those needs.

Patients who are unable to perform activities of daily living, such as dressing, walking, or eating independently, require more nursing and nurse aide hours per day than patients who are able to perform these tasks independently.

By accepting patients who are unable to care for their own needs, nursing home owners promise to provide enough nursing staff, both in quality and quantity, to deliver the appropriate care to each of those patients.

Poor Staffing Equals Poor Care.

Nursing home profits are tied to income and expenses. There are some expenses that are variable, which means they are not fixed and can be increased or decreased as the nursing home owners wish. Nursing hours are one of the most important variable expenses in running a nursing home.

Some of the other expenses that are variable are: food, supplies, and support staff (such as dietitians and rehabilitation specialists).

Nursing homes become dangerous places when their owners, in an effort to increase profits, fail to provide enough nurses or nurses' aides to care for the needs of their patients.

Our Next Article.

Our next article will discuss staffing specifics and provide a method of assessing the adequacy of staffing.

The “Guardian Blog” will continue to provide information to help families assess the quality of nursing home care in Arizona and the Guardian Blog will encourage dialog with and among its readers.

How Many Nurses Does It Take?

You’ve been told that your spouse or parent needs nursing home care.  You know that the nursing staff is important but what do you do next? First, you start by realizing that not all nursing homes are created equal.

Always evaluate several nursing homes to determine which facility best meets the needs of your loved one.

Although no single criteria should be the deciding factor, staffing levels are an important consideration in choosing a facility.

In evaluating staffing levels at the various facilities, there are a series of steps one must take. It is not easy but with some effort you can minimize the risk that your loved one will be placed in a facility that is unable to properly care for them.

Patient Needs.

What are the patient’s needs? Has the patient suffered a stroke, and now requires assisted feeding and assistance with ambulation? Does the patient suffer from dementia with a tendency to wander requiring a secured facility?

Use the following rule of thumb: The greater the need, the greater the number of staff necessary to care for the patient.

Nurse and Nurse Aides Available to Care for Patient Needs.

Arizona has no minimum requirement for the number of nurses or nurse aides a facility must have on duty at any given time.

Based on Arizona’s failure to require a minimum staffing level, Arizona nursing homes rank low nationally in the number of nursing staff available to care for patients.

The average number of nurses and nurse aides reported for Arizona facilities is 3.5 nursing hours per patient day. As a means of comparison, 82% of the states have a higher average number of nursing staff available to care for patients. Harrington, Carrillo, and Blank, Department of Social and Behavioral Sciences, University of California, September, 2008.

How to Calculate Nursing Hours per Patient Day.

1. Add the total nursing hours for all nurses on duty on any given day.

2. Divide the total nursing hours by the patient census (number of patients at the facility) for the same period of time.

Example: 2 nurses each working 8 hours in a facility that has 10 patients.

2x8=16 divided by 10 patients = 1.6 nurse staffing hours per patient day

Where to get the Staffing Schedules.

Every nursing home is required to post its current staffing schedule in the facility for the public to view.

The staffing schedule will contain information such as how many nurses, nurses' aides, and patients there are in the facility on any given day.

If after calculating the number of combined nurses and nurses aide hours at the facility, and if you arrive at a number less than 3.5 nursing hours per patient day, then you know that your facility does not even meet the staffing level of the average Arizona nursing home.

Visit the Facility.

There is no substitute for personally visiting the nursing home. Try to visit on a Sunday afternoon, as that is when most families are there to see their loved ones. Speak with several families and ask them whether they believe there are enough nurses or nurse’s aides there to be attentive to the patients.

Other Factors to Evaluate.

There are two government websites that you should look at for each facility you are considering. Each will give you information based upon inspections made by the Arizona Department of Health Services:

Finding the right nursing home is not based on a scientific formula, but instead is dependent on research and common sense. Even under the best of circumstances, family members must be attentive to the condition of their loved ones as well as the condition of the facility.

Our Next Article.

Our next article will discuss how to be attentive to the condition of your loved one in a nursing home.

The “Guardian Blog” will provide information to help both families and professionals assess and improve the quality of nursing home care in Arizona and the Guardian Blog will encourage dialog with and among its readers.
 

Is Mom Getting Good Care in that Nursing Home?

When an Arizona parent needs nursing home care, overseeing that care usually falls on whichever child happens to live in Arizona. This article is for that “responsible” child who just happens to live here.

The first question one must ask is whether any patient can receive quality care in a nursing home. We’ve all heard the horror stories about the warehousing of nursing home patients, who are just waiting to die.

Although nursing home care in Arizona is often less than adequate, I believe that it is possible for nursing home patients to receive quality care. However, in order to receive that level of care, patients must have a knowledgeable advocate.

Nursing Home Advocacy 101.

Nursing home advocacy doesn’t require a degree in nursing or medicine, just time, tenacity, and a little information.

Communication is the First Lesson.

One of the major problems in the nursing home is lack of communication between and among families, nursing staff, and physicians.

So how do you, as the patient’s advocate open channels of communication?

Become Aware of the Patient’s Needs.

Become aware of your loved one’s needs. Are they bed bound? Can they feed themselves? Are they taking a new medication?

Communication Just Doesn’t Happen by Itself.

Very few families understand that they have to become involved in facilitating communication within the nursing home.

Families are led to believe that the nursing staff will provide the physician with all the information about the patients. Families are also led to believe that the nursing staff will provide all the nursing care the patient requires. Unfortunately, both of these assumptions are not correct.

Nurses and nurses' aides are short staffed in nursing homes and are unable to provide all the necessary care the patients require. Physicians, who are responsible for the care of patients at nursing homes, rely too heavily on the nursing staff to follow physician orders or to perform adequate nursing care.

Meet with the Patient’s Nursing Home Physician.

Discuss your loved one’s needs, in person, with the nursing home's primary care physician. Find out when the physician plans to be at the facility for his regular visits with the patients, and meet him there.

Patient advocates must take steps to encourage physicians to personally take a close look at their loved one’s condition and ensure that the nursing staff is functioning as intended.

So, when meeting with physicians at the nursing home, ask them to check the condition of the patient. For example, if the patient appears to be losing weight, ask the physician to weigh the patient. If the patient has in fact lost weight, ask the physician to meet with you, the dietitian, and the nursing staff to discuss how to encourage weight gain.

The advocate may become a “pest”, but the physician won’t be able to say that he had no idea that his orders weren’t being followed or that he was unaware that the patient’s condition has changed.

It is the primary physician’s responsibility to know the care your loved one is receiving at the nursing home. If the patient is losing weight, the physician should determine why the patient is losing weight. The physician must ensure that his patient is eating his meals and if not, the reason why not. The physician must then take action to ensure adequate nutrition.

If the patient is bed bound, the physician needs to examine the patient’s skin in order to determine whether his patient is developing pressure ulcers (bed sores). And, if the patient has pressure ulcers, the physician must ensure that his patient is being turned and repositioned regularly and is also receiving adequate nutrition.

The advocate must be the vehicle by which the physician is encouraged to completely check the patient’s status, during each visit, and not merely rely on what he is being told or not being told by the nursing staff.

Make Regular Visits to the Nursing Home.

When you visit your loved one in the nursing home, visit during the morning, lunch, and evening meals which are the busiest times of the day. This will give you the opportunity to determine whether the nursing staff is able to attend to patient needs during stressful situations.

During your visits, check the following and report any changes you observe to the nursing staff and the patient’s physician:

1. Patient’s weight.
2. The percentage of breakfast, lunch and dinner the patient has eaten.
3. The patient’s skin condition (twice a week) for signs of red, blistered, or broken skin on hips, buttocks, shoulders, or any place that comes into contact with the mattress or wheel chair cushion.
4. The patient’s medication record documenting medications that were supposed to be given.
5. Look for any change in the patient’s condition including eating patterns, sleep patterns, falls, bowel movements, agitation, etc.

Meet the Director of Nursing.

The Director of Nursing (DON) is the highest level of nurse management in the nursing home. Introduce yourself to the DON and explain what you know about your loved one’s needs, likes, and dislikes. The DON is responsible for making sure there are enough nursing staff at the facility and is the “go to” person when nursing care isn’t up to par.

If, as a result of your observations, the patient is not receiving adequate care, speak with the DON and the patient’s physician.

If matters don’t improve, speak with the Administrator, who is the general manager of the nursing home.

If there still is no improvement, consider moving the resident to another facility. If matters are such that you decide to move the patient you should inform the Arizona Department of Health Services (ADHS) which is the regulatory agency in Arizona responsible for overseeing nursing homes.

The patient advocate is the additional oil that keeps the nursing home engine running well. When the oil is low and the engine spurts, the advocate is there to move things along.

It is unfortunate that nursing home patients need an outside observer and facilitator to get the care that Medicare and Arizona Long Term Care have paid for, and that patients are entitled to receive.

Our Next Article.

Our next article will discuss avoidable pressure ulcers (bed sores), a principal killer of nursing home patients.

The “Guardian Blog” will continue to provide information to help both families and professionals assess and improve the quality of nursing home care in Arizona and the Guardian Blog will encourage dialog with and among its readers.